Do Betta Fish Need a Filter?

Betta fish is the most controversial species of the gourami family, arguing on many of its topics. Whether or not betta fish require a filter is a much-debated topic among fish enthusiasts. There are arguments on both sides, with some saying a filter is essential for a betta’s health, while others claim bettas can thrive without one.

Below, I’ve reorganized the perspectives to help you understand both sides and the conditions under which each viewpoint applies.

Role of Filter in Betta Tank?

Before jumping into the discussion about the need for a filter for a betta fish, it’s worth learning what the purpose of a filter is. The answer to this question will reveal the fact about the need for filters for betta fish.

A filter in a fish tank is a device in which water is pulled through a pump or flow system and passes through a media in order to remove debris, harmful bacteria, or other toxic chemicals from the water. A filter media can be:

• A sponge, filter pad, or mesh material, removing the debris (such as uneaten food) from the tank. (Mechanical filtration)
• Bio balls or ceramic rings, allowing the beneficial bacteria to grow for nitrification. (Biological filtration)
• Or an activated carbon, removing the tennis or medication residues from the water. (Chemical filtration)

Do Betta Fish Need a Filter?

Now comes the debatable question: do betta fish need a filter?

The answer to this question can’t be answered simply in Yes or No. It depends upon several factors, including tank size, flow rate, type of betta, and compatibility with plants and decorations. If yes, what is the best filter for a betta fish tank? And if not, how long can they live without a filter? What are the other alternatives to be used in filterless tanks?

Betta fish don’t necessarily need a filter, but it’s highly recommended. Depending on the care, you can keep your betta alive without a filter for a time, but he will not thrive in this case. While betta fish can survive without a filter in specific conditions, using a filter significantly reduces maintenance efforts and ensures a more stable, healthy environment. Without a filter, you must perform more frequent water changes to control ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate levels.

Do Bettas Have Filters in Wild?

You might wonder why the betta experts focus on using the filter in tanks if no filter is installed in their natural habitats. In the wild, betta fish live in slow-moving waters, like rice paddies, shallow ponds, and streams, which have natural filtration processes. They contain plants and microorganisms and have a constant flow of water, which helps to break down waste, remove toxins, and oxygenate the water. In aquariums, these natural processes are ensured by using the filters. If you are not using the betta tank filter, you are depriving your betta of these natural processes.

Misconceptions About Bettas and Filters

A common misconception is that bettas, being hardy fish, can thrive in unfiltered tanks or even small bowls. While they can survive in such conditions, it is not ideal for their long-term health.

Most betta owners argue that in the wild, bettas breathe from the water surface using their labyrinth organs, which makes them capable of living in tanks without filters. However, keep in mind that a filter not only oxygenates the tank; instead, it has many other benefits that are crucial for the prosperous life of betta fish.

Betta Tanks without Filter

Avoiding filters in betta tanks will require more effort to maintain the tank conditions. In filterless setups, it becomes more challenging to ensure better care of the fish. In such tanks, water quality deteriorates quickly, leading to stress, disease, and a shorter lifespan of the fish. Stagnant water in betta tanks increases the buildup of harmful bacteria, parasites, and fungi that may lead to severe health concerns like fin rot, ich, and other bacterial or fungal diseases.

You may need to perform large weekly water changes to keep ammonia and nitrite levels to the least minimum. Water changes must be done every 24-72 hours to avoid health risks to the fish.

Those who choose to go filterless tanks will need to have a larger tank, a heavily planted setup, and regular water changes.

Benefits of Filter

A filter in a betta tank removes organic and inorganic wastes through biological, mechanical, and chemical filtration. The filter media allows bacterial biofilm to thrive, which aids in completing the nitrogen cycle, a process in which harmful ammonia is converted into nitrites and then further into less harmful nitrates. If no filter is used, the increased level of ammonia and nitrites can lead to betta health issues.

A filter in an aquarium traps solid debris such as fish waste, uneaten food, and plant matter. These things can make the water dirtier and unsuitable for bettas to live in. A filter also ensures better water circulation, oxygenation, and clarity.

A filter simplifies tank maintenance, reduces maintenance efforts, and makes the hobby more friendly for beginners.

To reap all these benefits, you’ll need to use a filter in betta tanks. Otherwise, you’ll need to perform an extreme level of tank care and experience difficulty maintaining the water conditions.

Factors to Consider When Using a Filter

It’s not as simple as putting a filter in a tank and just waiting for the result. Instead, you’ll need to consider certain factors while using it.

Tank Size Considerations

It’s advisable not to keep the betta in a tank smaller than 2.5-gallon, as it’s the least recommended. However, if you opt for one on a temporary basis, it’s recommended not to use the filter in a tank of this size. We suggest so for two reasons.

First, you’ll find it very challenging to fit the filter on the tank appropriately. Second, in tanks smaller than 2.5-gallon, the filter can cause too much water flow due to the limited volume of water, which is not in favor of betta fish. You’ll need frequent water changes (every 2-3 days) to maintain water quality. If you must use a filter, consider a sponge filter or gentle nano filter that creates slow water currents.

For any tank greater than 2.5-gallon, filters are highly recommended.

Tank Size	Best Filter Type	Why
2.5 – 5 gallons	Sponge Filter	Gentle flow, affordable, great for small tanks and betta fry tanks.
5 – 10 gallons	Sponge Filter or HOB Filter	Sponge for gentler flow. HOB if chemical filtration is needed.
10 – 20 gallons	HOB or Internal Filter	HOB for ease of use and complete filtration. Use baffle to reduce water flow. Internal filter if space-saving is important.
20 gallons+	HOB or Canister Filter	Canister for larger, heavily stocked tanks. HOB filter for moderate setups.

Remember, these filter types’ recommendations for the respective tank size are not the final ones and are not harsh to follow. You can go for any type of filter that seems to suit your needs and those of your betta.

Flow Rate

Bettas do not appreciate strong water currents due to their long, delicate fins, which can make swimming difficult. The strong current of water can cause the betta from swim bladder disease. You need to opt for sponge filters or other low-flow filters that provide gentle water movement without stressing the fish.

Filter Size

The size of the filter should match the tank size to ensure it fits well and provides adequate filtration. A large filter in a small tank may cause excessive water movement, while a small filter in a large tank may not be efficient. Always match the filter size to the tank capacity.

Highly Recommended for Beginners

A filter is highly recommended for those new to the fish hobby in general and betta care in particular. A beginner might experience serious difficulty remedying the effects of not using the filter. Newbies usually don’t have a practical understanding of tank maintenance, such as the nitrogen cycle and heavily planted setups. They must use filters in their betta tanks; otherwise, they may experience serious consequences of tank degradation.

If we even suggest going without a filter, compensation is only for experienced betta keepers who are skilled in betta care.

Best Betta Filter Recommendations

1. Marineland Penguin Bio-Wheel Power Filter

Check it on Amazon

This filter is our top recommendation for its long-lasting durability and easy maintenance. It uses the bio-wheel technology, which provides excellent biological filtration. Additionally, the filter brings out mechanical, biological, and chemical filtration, keeping the tank clean from every aspect. It comes in five different sizes, suiting best to your needs. Being an HOB filter, it might work well for your larger tank, but upon our testing, we considered it best for something smaller than 10 gallons because it lacks the power and efficiency needed for bigger tanks. If you are starting out, surely opt for this filter.

2. Tetra Whisper IQ Power Filter for 20 Gallons

Check it on Amazon

This is the filter we are using for our own 20-gallon betta tank. Without exaggeration, the Tetra Filter is our most favored betta tank filter for its quietness, customizability, and excellent flow control, which are crucial for betta fish. While it requires regular cleaning and maintenance, its durability and performance make it worth it. Additionally, the flexibility to use your own media can save you money in the long run. I highly recommend this filter for your betta tank.

Replacement Cartridges

If you are using the sponge filter and need replacement filter cartridges, the Aqueon Replacement Cartridges (Check it on Amazon) are the best to go for. They come in multiple sizes, which you can buy according to your tank requirement. These cartridges are easy to install and have a high-quality activated carbon.

Alternatives to Filter

If you have difficulty going with a filter, likely because of tank size, compatibility with fish or plants, or any other reason, there are other alternatives. Experienced fish keepers attempt other techniques to mimic natural filtration.

Walstad Method

The widely used method, recommended by most betta aquarists, is the Walstad method. In this technique, a heavily planted setup is created with a deep substrate to ensure dense plant growth. Plants perform the natural filtration process by absorbing nitrates and helping stabilize the ecosystem.

Remember, this method requires at least 30-40% plant cover and substantial maintenance, including frequent water changes to reduce waste. Additionally, you can perform the process in a larger tank (at least 10 gallons).

We recommend the Walstad technique only when you have a better understanding of how plants and bacteria balance the water’s chemistry. Although this technique is not equivalent to traditional filters, it’s far better than filterless setups.

Conclusion

Hopefully, it’s evident to you what aquarium filters are. Why do we add them to fish tanks? And do betta fish need them or not? We conclude our comprehensive guide about the betta tank filters into more simple and concise words.

While it is possible to keep a betta in a tank without a filter, it is not ideal. Even in filterless setups, adding a small, quiet filter can significantly improve water quality and reduce the frequency of water changes.

If you choose to go without a filter, be prepared for a larger tank, more frequent water changes, and live plants to assist with water quality. Bettas thrive in clean, well-maintained tanks, and filters play an essential role in achieving that. For most betta owners, especially beginners, using a filter is the best option for maintaining a healthy, happy fish.

FAQs